Voting out the far-right


by Chris Dillow    
May 29, 2008 at 11:33 am

Mike Ion thinks the Labour leadership should do more to combat the rise of the BNP:

Gordon Brown would send out a powerful message to his party’s core supporters if he were to personally throw his weight behind a call for a new “coalition of the willing” that will help to blunt the advance of the far-right in this country by addressing some of the genuine concerns of white working-class voters while at the same time openly challenging those concerns that have no factual or legitimate basis.

I fear Mike’s plea will go unheeded. The fact is that our electoral system gives Labour little incentive to fight the far-right, or listen to its core supporters.
Labour will not lose the next election because of the rise of the BNP in places like Stoke (Mike’s example).

It makes no difference if Labour’s 10,000 majorities in Stoke’s constituencies are cut by thousands because of the BNP or abstainers.

What will cost Labour the election is the loss of places like Worcester or Oxford West. And although abstentions or BNP votes by white working class voters in those areas could be a problem, they are less a danger than middle-income floating voters swinging to the Tories. It was his grasp of this fact that helped Blair win three elections.

So, could it be that ignoring its core support - and the rise in the BNP this threatens - is one of the prices we must pay for our first-past-the-post system?

· About the author: Chris Dillow is a regular contributor to Liberal Conspiracy. He is a former City economist and now an economics writer. He is also the author of The End of Politics: New Labour and the Folly of Managerialism. Also at: Stumbling and Mumbling

· Other posts by Chris Dillow

· About this article:
Print it   |   Trackback link   |   Track comments   |   send to del.icio.us   |   to Facebook
Filed under: Blog , Our democracy , Race relations , Realpolitik


2 Comments in response   ||   Add your own



at 12:22 pm on May 29, 2008
- direct link -  
1.  comment by
     MatGB

So, could it be that ignoring its core support - and the rise in the BNP this threatens - is one of the prices we must pay for our first-past-the-post system?

For as long as we’ve got it, yes. Both Downs and Duverger, and all the subsequent research based on their analysis, shows this to be true. It does of course cause problems at a local level and on councils, but that’s how First Past the Post works.

STV is naturally a much better way of ensuring this isn’t a problem, as you need to appeal to all voters and make sure you don’t marginalise your core support, under FPTP they’ve not really got anywhere else to go :-(

at 12:37 pm on May 29, 2008
- direct link -  
2.  comment by
     Different Duncan

Agreed. FPTP means that Labour need not worry too much about the BNP. The BNP may gain votes, but they won’t gain seats.

A little confused you mentioned Oxford West. This is Lib Dem held (by the thoroughly excellent Evan Harris), with the Tories in 2nd. I can’t see how this has anything to do with your point…

Post a comment using the form below

  • We have a tight comments policy aimed at fostering constructive debate.
  • We believe in free speech but not your right to abuse our space.
  • Abusive, sarcastic or silly comments may be deleted.
  • Misogynist, racist, homophobic and xenophobic comments will be deleted.
  • Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy.

HERE AND THERE
Featured blogs

Boris - the gaffopedia


David Lammy MP -

Can we follow Obama's lead?


Lynne Featherstone MP -

What about the dads?



Recently popular
Palin, abortion and the gender agenda
(331 replies)

The 'Gordon Brown is insane' meme
(164 replies)

A-Z of right-wing online commenting
(117 replies)

Lesbian mothers and 'traditional' families
(112 replies)

We should have open primaries for elections
(108 replies)

Latest comments
» thomas posted on Election '08: The final straight

» thomas posted on Call Me Mystic Unity

» Darrell posted on John Redwood: let the banking system collapse

» Darrell posted on John Redwood: let the banking system collapse

» Diogenes posted on John Redwood: let the banking system collapse

» Lee Griffin posted on Election '08: The final straight

» douglas clark posted on Call Me Mystic Unity

» douglas clark posted on John Redwood: let the banking system collapse

» Kate Belgrave posted on Call Me Mystic Unity

» douglas clark posted on Election '08: The final straight

» Paul posted on John Redwood: let the banking system collapse

» leon posted on Election '08: The final straight

» Nick posted on John Redwood: let the banking system collapse

» Aaron Heath posted on Call Me Mystic Unity

» Banditry » Blog Archive » Back, and an apology of sorts posted on The Left-wing response to the financial crisis

  Last 50 // Comments feed